Twenty years ago, everything changed. For us, maybe not everyday life, but parts of life--both physical and mental--shifted forever. Twenty years ago today, September 11th changed the world.
No, we personally didn't lose anyone. We don't live in New York City. Heck, I haven't been there since it happened, though Craig did visit while the pile was still there. But life changed nonetheless. The airport became a more challenging place to be. I know I still tend to eyeball the people on my flights a bit more than I should. New York City will always hold some sadness, if only because when watching old episodes of Friends you periodically get the reminder of what the skyline once was. Fire drills in office buildings feel different. And maybe most of all, our entire sense of security as a country was shattered, and never really recovered.
Craig and I were watching a documentary tonight and he remarked how frustrating it was that they were telling people in the towers to stay in their offices or go back up after the first plane hit. And yes, it is sad that people who likely could have made it out then never got the chance later. But obviously there was debris falling, which wasn't safe either, and I reminded him that the entire concept of it being a terrorist attack wasn't clear at the time, and even if it was, who in a billion years would have assumed someone else was coming for the other tower? We couldn't begin to fathom what was happening in the first place, and an attack of that level was unheard of. If it happened now, sure, we'd assume the worst. But only because we've seen the worst. At that point we just hadn't witnessed something so brazen and massive to ever assume those other folks would be in that kind of danger. No one could fathom the buildings' collapse, either, so of course it seemed like those people were safe where they were. Even now watching footage it's hard to believe it even happened--any of it, from the planes and the towers to the collapse and the hole in the Pentagon and the legendary stories from Flight 93 in Pennsylvania.
But it did, and I still remember it thoroughly. I've related it here before, but as a refresher: I was running late to work, and as I strolled in a little after 9 past Craig's desk, I heard him say a plane had hit the World Trade Center, but we still thought it was a small plane then. I don't remember hearing specifically about the second plane, but at some point apparently it was concerning enough that we moved into the Amerks' locker room to watch footage. After a bit, I remember watching a reporter at the Pentagon, who was waiting for some sort of government update, report that they'd heard a very loud boom. At first they thought it was a car bomb or something, but I don't think I heard until a bit later that it, too, was a plane. In the meantime, we were watching the fires at the towers, and through sort of fuzzy reception, I couldn't believe my eyes when I realized we were watching a tower collapse. I will never forget my complete disbelief as the smoke and debris cleared enough to show blue sky where the building once was, realizing that one of the tallest buildings in the world was simply no longer there. And of course, it got worse when the second tower fell, and in the midst of it all, slowly realizing the human horror of what had just happened--from people in the buildings to the ones on the ground. It was inconceivable. Eventually I tried to go back to my desk and either try to find some work to do or at least search the (very slow, overloaded) internet, which was not yet awash in news sources or social media, for information. In fact, that's probably one of the other things September 11th subtly changed--I feel like internet news got far more sophisticated soon after. The previous day was our work golf tournament so I know had wrap-up to do, and it was only a month from our opener so I was worried about being unproductive for a day or week. Little did I know that most of our national advertisers would make my job very hard for a while, as they put all of their advertising on a freeze for weeks due to all the uncertainty. We spent the day moving between the locker room TV and my boss's small black and white one at his desk. It was a terribly unproductive day, in addition to being simply terrifying until the hijacked plane reports finally seemed to have stopped. Then I remember driving home and hearing not only that WTC 7 collapsed, but that the Stevie Nicks concert that was coming to Rochester that week, which Mary and I had tickets for, had been canceled--never to be rescheduled, by the way. Such a first-world problem, of course, but it felt like adding insult to injury at that point. Craig and I were newly dating at the time, and I know I was too exhausted to make dinner that night, so we ended up going on one of our early dates to the Ruby Tuesday in Greece that opened the previous day. That location actually closed a couple years back and a new Mexican restaurant just opened there. Anyway, I recall just sitting at our table, mindlessly eating while watching news coverage of the recovery effort and reruns of footage from earlier in the day. It didn't make stomaching dinner easy, but it was all we could do to simply function at that point. After that it was days of news coverage after work that I eventually had to actively prevent myself from watching because it was just too depressing. The thought of so many grieving families, either not knowing what happened to their loved ones or getting bad news, so many kids losing parents, so many parents losing grown children, the thoughts of the last moments of those in the buildings or on the planes, all of it was overwhelming. It honestly still is.
We watched a lot of documentaries on the anniversary in the early years. I still remember being fascinated by the one done by the French brothers who had been doing a documentary about rookie firefighters and caught footage of one of the planes hitting. But as we've had kids, our viewing has decreased. Some of it is probably busyness, some of it is fear of that grief and not wanting to actively relive it, and some is probably a desire to not have the kids watch the terror. Jacob's probably old enough now to process it properly, but just the other day I had to explain again to Carter what September 11th was all about and felt the need to keep it really simple. It's weird being 20 years out, having kids of our own who have never known a life without that piece of history, and trying to wrangle our own sadness and figure out the appropriateness of sharing it with our kids. On one hand, it's real history. It's something they'll learn about, and having been alive for it, we have our own insights to share. On the other hand, as a parent you naturally try to shield your kids from sadness or nightmare-inducing stuff. It's one thing in a fake movie, it's another when it's a real-life thing that actually happened (and in their minds, could happen again). And I guess I'm still trying to find that balance. This was our Pearl Harbor, and I'm not sure I ever asked my grandparents for their take on the actual Pearl Harbor...but I wish I had to know what they would have shared. It's just so hard to know what's appropriate, what's important, and how to manage it without traumatizing them.
Even after living it, twenty years out it's still so hard to fathom. It's almost half my life ago now. How do you make sense of something that was so monumental, that destroyed so many lives, and fundamentally changed so much in our country? Part of me wants to watch all the shows and ceremonies to process and mourn, but part of me can't risk being sucked into the terror and grief I felt that day and the days after. It was debilitating. And yet, getting all worked up about something that happened 20 years ago seems...unnecessary at best and disingenuous at worst. But who can watch it without feeling it deeply? It's a vicious circle. It's such a weird feeling to still not know how to memorialize this day, even after 19 years of them.
For many years my mood was impacted by the weather. If it was a perfect, clear blue sky, 70-degree fall day like it was that day, it was eerie. Those kind of days (even on days that aren't September 11th) still sometimes get to me, as do low flying planes. If September 11th is rainy, it feels oddly appropriate but strangely like an insult to those we lost. Today it was a lovely upper 70s day, and it felt pretty neutral. But inevitably I still have moments during the day where I think about what I was doing that day at that time.
Twenty years is such a long time. Babies born to dead dads just after are now bona fide adults. Those who were my age are now in their 60s. The youngest group to really remember it is pushing 30--and knowing that, it's weird to think back to January 2006 when I would have been in their shoes, 20 years after the Challenger disaster, the first big news story I remember well. That was huge, but it didn't have the same globally arresting impact that September 11th did.
Sometimes it feels easier all this time later (probably because I'm afraid to let myself really go back there), and sometimes I get a fresh wave of grief for all that was lost when I read a new story I hadn't heard before, which I have a number of times this week. Just today there was a local news story about a woman born in Rochester who lost her husband of four months that day. She married again and had three kids, only to lose a second husband this summer. To think of that level of loss in these last 20 years, it's heartbreaking, and she's probably not much older than me. I read a very long article tonight about the parents and the almost-fiancee of a victim who had a falling out over his last journal, which his dad gave to the girlfriend without asking the mom, and how some emotional decisions over that journal had all these reverberations through their respective existences in the 20 years since. There are literally thousands of stories out there, and likely thousands more since from people who suffered from related illnesses due to the dust cloud or fumes during the lengthy recovery efforts. It's crushing to know that's all out there and those numbers keep rising to this day.
It's so odd to realize how certain emotions have dulled and some are still so vivid all these years later. Grief is a funny thing, and while mine may not have been super personal, it still didn't go in a very straight line. As an empath, it sometimes kills me to think of the sadness that's out there to this day, and the intense suffering that happened back then. It's still a lot to process, and that may never end. In fact, with all these varied emotions 20 years in, I can probably safely say it won't ever end completely. And maybe before I know it, I will have grandkids asking me about it. I hope so anyway, because we should never, ever forget that day and those that were lost.


