I had really hoped we wouldn't have to go through this process again...but I suppose deep down I should have known. Jacob is changing schools. Again.
As I mentioned previously, he got sick a couple weeks ago and it coincided with a teammate coming to practice sick. Even though what Jacob had was different, it seemed to trigger some anxiety that goes back to last school year when one of his teammates kept coming to practice sick and then Jacob got the flu. He's been very sensitive to catching an illness for the last couple years because he feels like anything he gets could set back his recovery of his leg issues. That just seemed to start a domino effect of all of his grievances with the school, from his disruptive and direction-less classmates, to the constant merry-go-round of teachers, to losing two faculty to jail sentences, to drug use and violence in the school, to lazy and disrespectful teammates. He sees stupidity and instinctively wants to fix it, and is eaten alive by the injustice that comes with broken rules with no consequences or moving goalposts. That's just not good for his mental health, and after complaining about it for the better part of a year, he just couldn't take it anymore. And knowing that the educational experience is nowhere near what any of us want it to be, it just didn't make sense to keep pushing it. The school tried to work with us, but nothing was ever the same after his basketball coach (who did hold the team to high standards) left. At that point, I'm not sure there's any way they could control things enough to right the ship.
The good news, if you can call it that, is that this was a legit mental health issue, as verified by his therapist, which meant that he could be eligible for a mental health waiver. That's one of the very few ways that he could transfer yet again and still play basketball, despite Section V's ridiculously strict rules. We could have moved, but we definitely couldn't afford that, and even then there's usually some lead time on that. There was the apartment idea we talked about a lot last year, renting an apartment in another district (which would also technically involve a legal separation (!) to illustrate why the new address was needed) and somehow juggling living there, maybe with one parent at a time. That would have been a mess. But we needed to find a way to get him in a better place, as there was no doubt in our minds that his mental health was struggling. We were armed with lots of examples, and his therapist was able to validate what issues they had talked about in sessions. So the waiver it was.
After being out sick for three days the first full week of school with stomach problems, last week he ended up staying home so he could start browsing other school options--tours, meeting with admissions, etc. He was still refusing to even consider our district schools, so it looked like we'd have to go private.
The first front-runner was McQuaid, the rather expensive all-boys Catholic school. The upsides of that one were great academics, close to my office, and a late start time. The downside was that they just had some transfers come in that would risk Jacob not being able to start on the basketball team. It was also the most expensive option. He really liked his tour, and for a while that was the front runner, until we found out about the basketball situation.
I sometimes say that Craig is too good of a dad, as he will often try to move heaven and earth to help out his kids, even to his own detriment. When there were doubts about McQuaid, he started looking into the possibility of Jacob moving to Buffalo, staying with family, and going to his former high school, St. Francis. There's a long family history there, and their basketball program could really use him. Section VI doesn't have many rules about transfers, especially out of area, so he'd be fine to play. The academics would be great, and he liked the facilities. He also liked the idea of being a "legacy" there, as our name is very well-known in the school and town. Of course, there's just one problem--we don't live in Buffalo and we have jobs that don't let us move there. So that would mean he'd have to move there alone and stay with family. That felt nearly impossible to me because Jacob is super high maintenance, needs a special diet, and tends to be rather attached to us. He hasn't really proven he can be independent and we spend half of our spare time now talking him down from whatever's on his mind. So how on earth could we do that from a distance or expect someone else to handle all of that in our absence? We could try to go up weekly to maybe spend a day up there working remotely and then bring him home for the weekend. But that would be exhausting, and I feel like we'd be spending our evenings on FaceTime most of the time--if not for a problem, then for him to remain connected to what's happening here when he's inevitably homesick. We'd be on the Thruway multiple times a week, especially in-season for games. In my mind, managing all of his things from afar (or needing to trust other people) seemed overwhelming. Not to mention that he can be a bit fickle and the slightest thing can set him off, so what happens when we go through all of this craziness and find out he doesn't like it and wants to come home? It just seemed like a giant risk for a kid who's already an established school-hopper. But he really liked the tour and how he was treated there, so that leapfrogged McQuaid in his mind even though we were insisting it was a last resort.
Now, some people (including Jacob) would probably be like, "Well, he could have been leaving for college a year from now anyway if he didn't reclassify, so what's one year? What will you do when he actually goes away?" Well, for one, he DID reclassify and we have two more years, which is a lot of time to mature. Since he never cleans up his dishes or garbage or laundry, and rarely wants to make his own food, how the heck am I supposed to trust he'd do it elsewhere, in someone else's house? Second, college is a whole different ballgame because everyone's in the same boat and there's so much built-in structure. They're all experiencing that for the first time, and there's an entire support system to guide them, including RAs, a dining hall, and the shared experience of a whole group of kids figuring things out together (aka positive peer pressure and crowdsourcing). This would be very different because there would only be a handful of people in his situation, and even then it's so different for everyone. Also, at college, the expectation is that you stay at school nearly every weekend. It's the best way to integrate into a community and experience the fun side of college. But with this situation, it feels like not bringing him home would be an abandonment of our responsibilities and an added burden on others. But six hours on the Thruway each weekend? Ugh.
So, obviously I had a million doubts right off the bat, and while it was Craig's idea in the first place, he was slowly realizing how complicated it might get, even for basic things like doctor's appointments or his beloved trainer. So then we started considering Aquinas, one of the schools he considered way back before middle school, and then again when he was struggling earlier this year. He liked the prospect of where their basketball team stood and knew the coach was interested in him. It was a good school, convenient enough to home, and seemed like a solid option. But then he went to a fall league game and watched them play, only to find out their coach was an absolute screaming psychopath during games. Jacob's travel coach, James, confirmed Jacob wouldn't be able to play for him because of that, and that's likely why they've lost a number of good kids in recent years. So that option went out the window almost as quickly as it came in.
After his St. Francis tour last Tuesday, we ended up meeting with his current principal to share the news he wanted to leave. We had to get that ball rolling to even have a chance at making some of the schools' enrollment deadlines, as they would have to sign off. The principal was very understanding, and even handed over a withdrawal form right then. We also ran into his basketball coach on our way out and broke the news to him. That was pretty sad and we felt bad given all the history, but then again, there were so many reasons we felt we had to do this.
Once the Aquinas idea lost steam, McQuaid came back in the running, especially after his tour of their amazing facilities, but then he started talking more and more about St. Francis again. He just wasn't sure about McQuaid because of the basketball situation (and admittedly, the tuition was a little more than we'd prefer), so he began dissing the other options and really pushing St. Francis hard. I was still firmly protesting the entire idea until we were sure that Section V was not an option. His preference for the away-from-home option obviously frustrated me because it was clear he didn't realize how difficult that would be for all of us. Maybe to some degree it felt like he doesn't value the extreme amount of effort we put into his existence each day, but it was annoying that no amount of real-life examples of why it might be a problem seemed to be sinking in. For example, it would be harder to get him to his doctor appointments, his therapist, or his trainer. He wouldn't have as much control of his eating, and we'd have to trust someone else to shop for him and cook for him. He'd probably end up feeling isolated from our family and miss being here (since having to be at school long into the evenings during the season alone can do that). He'd put a lot of pressure on us to do all of those drives and be available to him in the evenings. He simply wasn't listening to very common sense challenges we'd face, and seemed to be vastly underestimating how much he'd need us (based on how much he needs us now). We are essentially at his beckon call, and I don't think he realizes how frustrating it might be to not have that same flexibility anymore. It killed us that Craig had spent most of his week trying to find options and getting approvals, and now Jacob seemed hellbent on making St. Francis happen even though it was the hardest, most complicated option on our list. Fortunately, Craig's parents were OK to take him in for now, and his brother was also on board once they got their own place when Craig's parents' new house is done. I still feel like it's not anyone else's responsibility, even though his brother and his wife are missing having any of their kids at home and would probably welcome something to fill that hole. Even still, it felt like a whole lot of unknowns and it still didn't sit entirely right with me.
Then, out of the blue, Bishop Kearney entered the chat. He had previously said no, but desperate times call for desperate measures, I guess. BK was the school he went to for middle school, and he did like it back then. He only had to switch schools because he reclassified and couldn't redo 8th grade there. But he still has a couple friends there and his favorite administrator is still there, too. His travel coach also verified that the basketball situation would probably be a good one for him. We had a very quick turnaround in talking to someone and getting him in for a tour and making tentative arrangements for enrollment. He also talked to the coach, and suddenly that became the front-runner.
However, although he seemed enthusiastic to begin with, he backslid back into the St. Francis talk, which was pretty much infuriating at this point. We (or really Craig) have been trying so hard to make something work locally, and here Jacob was dismissing it again and putting us in a position of him potentially stonewalling all of these efforts and insisting we let him move. I just don't think he gets how much pressure and burden that puts on everyone around him. Sigh.
Of course, all of this could have been a moot point because Section V still had to approve things. There's a plethora of evidence that this move is important to his well-being, but it's not just about whether he can transfer--he can--but rather whether he can transfer AND play. And that's important to his mental state as well. Of course, the woman who had to approve everything was on vacation Friday, which meant we wouldn't get a ruling until at least Monday. Tuesday was the last day Jacob could enroll at St. Francis, so if everything fell apart, we had a VERY short window to get a LOT of things figured out. We were being told that as long as all of the paperwork was in, it shouldn't be an issue, but we know how that process can go.
Jacob enrolled over the weekend and went to Bishop Kearney on Monday. He did his first official day of school and...he didn't love it. Part of me thinks that it's because he was pushing so hard for St. Francis that he wasn't giving this a fair shot. As I've said before, he's a "grass is greener" person, and I think he was discounting BK because he wanted to assume he'd be one-and-done there and be off to Buffalo. He started bringing up every excuse in the book about why he hated BK, ranging from not liking his female tour guide and it being the only school to not give him swag, to not liking the new casual uniform dress code because he wanted to wear a blazer (like McQuaid), to his annoyance with the teacher he needed to get his Chromebook from. He even said he didn't like BK when he went there before, which is absolute crap. Yes, he had one bad situation with the modified basketball team and how Jacob and a few friends were promised to go up to JV, but that changed the day before the season. They did bring everyone up late in the season, but I think by then we knew Jacob needed his eligibility to transfer and reclassify, so we kept him down. That situation worked to his advantage since he got to play Varsity at Northstar and win a sectional title, but at the time it definitely wasn't handled well. But that was an exception to an otherwise good experience. Yes, there were a couple issues, but for the most part we felt he liked it--he made his best friendships there, liked the class structure, and seemed to fit in well. But in the years since, his views have gotten a bit more conservative, and something like pride flags in a couple classrooms--despite it being a Catholic school--gets under his skin. He basically said he never consented to go there and was mad that he was stuck there now unless he didn't get approved to play.
Speaking of which, we didn't get an answer Monday like we thought. Then we were supposed to hear Tuesday morning, but that didn't happen either. At that point, Craig had to tentatively enroll Jacob at St. Francis, just in case, so that he didn't miss the winter sports deadline there. By this point, Jacob--who was actually home sick on BK day #2 with the cold we both caught--was actively cheering for Section V to say no so he could go to St. Francis, and we were getting pretty annoyed. We were told we'd get an answer first thing Wednesday, but right before dinner Tuesday, we got the text that he'd been approved. Obviously we were relieved, but that started a long few hours of him being upset and complaining incessantly about BK. Craig and I were so annoyed that we went out for a walk to decompress, only to have him call us while we were walking and start up another debate.
I was close to the point of just being like, fine, let's let him find out the hard way. But I can't overstate how risky it feels to go into a situation like that, with so many unknowns, but needing to try to stick with it for two whole years. There's a million reasons why I wish we could just move there and make it easy, but there's also a million reasons why that's nearly impossible. Is it just too much to ask for him to find the bright side of this new situation and make the best of it? He's away from the insanity at his old school, and the basketball almost HAS to be better. The coach is so excited to have him and I have to think the culture and skill level will be up at least a few notches. No, it's not his ideal situation he thought he'd have at St. Francis, but also, he has a massive safety net still being here with us, which should provide comfort and security equal to whatever benefit St. Francis would have provided. I think he also might have had high hopes for exploring his independence, which I agree could have been good, but maybe not at the expense of others' time and energy. He tends to be pretty high maintenance, and I don't see that ending anytime soon. As much as the people caring for him love him, it would be asking a lot to care for him. Also, there were so many areas in which that plan could fail--issues with the living situation, school, basketball team, or the distance--so it would be a big risk. We just don't have a good track record of him staying at a school for long, nor has he proven his ability to be independent either practically or emotionally. This would have taken just a bit too big of a leap of faith, you know?
So, here we are. He missed day #3 because of his cold, and is still complaining quite a bit about the whole situation. We keep reminding him that he literally had one day at school, so he can't really judge the whole experience by that. He says that he was always comfortable on his first days at other schools, but most of us recognize that first days are usually so awkward, so he was probably lucky before and will undoubtedly settle in over time--particularly once basketball gets going.
I'll be honest, I feel a little bit like a failed parent at this point. He has gone to four schools in five years, and still no sign of being content. We've spent a lot of time lately speculating on how we could have done things better, but truthfully, we made the best decisions we could at the time--even if we knew they had risks. RACS was definitely the riskiest, and sure enough, that situation played out pretty similarly to how I thought it could, although it probably took longer than I would have guessed. We're trying to err on the side of what we know because the alternative was just too much right now. It's a weird (but potentially wonderful) full circle moment going back there, and I truly hope he settles in and loves it again.
Jacob has proven yet again that there is literally never a dull moment with him, but let's hope this one sticks.